Hereâs the uncomfortable truth about productivity software: most task managers solve the wrong problem.
Theyâre brilliantly engineered solutions to âhow do I organize and track my tasks?â when the real problem people face is âwhich tasks should I actually work on today?â
Todoist is arguably the best task manager in existence. Seventeen years of refinement, 35 million users, rock-solid reliability, and elegant design. If your problem is task capture and organization, Todoist solves it exceptionally well.
But what if your problem isnât organization? What if youâre drowning in perfectly organized tasks and the real bottleneck is deciding what matters?
Thatâs the gap ThinkDone addresses. Not as a Todoist replacement, but as the planning intelligence layer that sits upstream from task execution.
This comparison isnât about declaring a winner. Itâs about understanding which problem youâre actually trying to solve â and which tool addresses it.
The Quick Verdict
Choose Todoist if:
- You know what you need to do and need a fast, reliable way to track it
- You work across multiple platforms (Windows, Android, Linux, web)
- You want mature, proven software with 17 years of refinement
- You prefer manual control over AI suggestions
- You need collaboration features for teams
Choose ThinkDone if:
- Youâre drowning in tasks and struggling with prioritization
- You want AI planning intelligence to decide what matters today
- You need a morning planning ritual that forces strategic thinking
- Youâre comfortable with a younger product still adding features
- Youâre solo or work with small teams
Use both if:
- You want strategic planning (ThinkDone) + tactical execution (Todoist)
- You value the morning planning conversation but need robust task tracking throughout the day
- You have complex projects requiring both planning intelligence and organizational structure
Todoist users worldwide
Doist company data, 2024
Philosophy: The Core Difference
The fundamental difference isnât features â itâs philosophical approach.
Todoistâs philosophy: Give users a fast, reliable, cross-platform tool for capturing and organizing tasks. Stay out of their way. Let them build whatever system works for them. Provide structure but donât prescribe methodology.
ThinkDoneâs philosophy: Most people donât need better task organization. They need better thinking about priorities. Provide a daily planning conversation that forces strategic decisions before the day starts, when decision-making capacity is highest.
We donât want to tell people how to be productive. We want to give them a tool that adapts to however they think about their work.
This explains their different strengths. Todoist is infinitely flexible â you can implement GTD, do bullet journaling, create Agile sprints, or invent your own system. ThinkDone is opinionated â it insists you start each day with a planning conversation, face your priorities explicitly, and commit to a realistic plan.
Neither approach is universally better. The question is which matches your needs.
Feature Comparison: Head to Head
Task Entry and Capture
Todoist: Natural language parsing thatâs been refined for 17 years. Type âCall dentist tomorrow at 2pm p1 #healthâ and Todoist parses date, time, priority, and project automatically. Fast entry across all platforms, including email forwarding (forward@todoist.com) and browser extensions.
ThinkDone: Conversational task entry during the planning meeting. Instead of parsing task syntax, you have a natural language conversation: âI need to call the dentist.â ThinkDone asks when, estimates time, and places it appropriately in your day.
Winner: Todoist â The natural language parsing is faster and works on every platform. ThinkDoneâs conversational approach is more thoughtful but slower for rapid task capture.
Prioritization and Planning
Todoist: Manual prioritization using four priority levels (P1-P4) or drag-to-reorder. Filters let you create custom views like âtoday | overdue & p1â. No AI assistance or suggestions. You decide everything.
ThinkDone: AI-powered daily planning conversation. Reviews your projects, asks about blockers, challenges your priorities, estimates time, and helps you build a realistic daily plan. Forces explicit prioritization through conversation.
Winner: ThinkDone â This is its core strength. If you struggle with prioritization or tend to overcommit, the AI planning conversation is transformative. Todoist leaves this entirely to you.
Organization and Structure
Todoist: Sophisticated organizational system with projects, sub-projects, sections, labels, and filters. Can create complex hierarchies like:
Work (project)
ââ Q1 Planning (sub-project)
ââ Client Projects (sub-project)
â ââ sections: Active, Waiting, Done
ââ Admin (sub-project)
Labels act as cross-project tags (@urgent, @email, @calls). Filters create dynamic views using boolean logic.
ThinkDone: Simpler project structure focused on areas of responsibility and active projects. Less hierarchical nesting. Organization serves the planning conversation rather than being the primary interface.
Winner: Todoist â Far more sophisticated organization for complex personal systems or multi-project tracking. ThinkDone is intentionally simpler, prioritizing planning over organization.
Cross-Platform and Sync
Todoist:
- Web (PWA with offline support)
- Native apps: Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, Android
- Wearables: Apple Watch, Wear OS
- Integrations: 80+ including Gmail, Outlook, Slack, Zapier
- Sync is near-instant and rock-solid
ThinkDone:
- Web app (PWA)
- In development: iOS, Android, desktop apps
- Limited integrations (early stage)
Winner: Todoist â Not even close. Seventeen years of platform development vs. a new product. If you need cross-platform access or work on Windows/Android, Todoist is the clear choice.
Collaboration and Teams
Todoist:
- Shared projects with task assignment
- Comments and file attachments
- Team inbox for centralized task collection
- Admin roles and team billing
- Business tier: $6/user/month
ThinkDone:
- No collaboration features (currently personal-focused)
- Roadmap includes shared planning for small teams
Winner: Todoist â ThinkDone doesnât compete here yet. If you need team features, Todoist wins by default.
Intelligence and Automation
Todoist:
- No AI features (as of early 2025)
- Templates for recurring project setups
- Recurring task patterns (sophisticated but manual)
- No smart suggestions or predictive features
ThinkDone:
- AI planning conversation every morning
- Context-aware suggestions based on past behavior
- Time estimation help using historical patterns
- Blocker detection and project health assessment
- Strategic pattern recognition (notices neglected projects)
Winner: ThinkDone â This is where the products diverge most dramatically. Todoist is a traditional task manager. ThinkDone is an AI planning partner. If you want intelligence help, ThinkDone provides it.
The Role of Planning in Goal Achievement
Gollwitzer, Peter M. & Sheeran, Paschal (2006) · American Psychologist
Key finding: Implementation intentions (specific if-then plans) increase goal achievement rates by 2-3x compared to simple goal-setting. The act of planning when, where, and how to act significantly improves follow-through.
Download PDFPricing
Todoist:
- Free: 5 active projects, unlimited tasks, basic functionality
- Pro: $4/month (or $36/year) â unlimited projects, reminders, labels, filters
- Business: $6/user/month â team features
ThinkDone:
- Free tier: 5 planning sessions/month
- Pro: $8/month or $80/year â unlimited planning, advanced features
- Team: (in development)
Winner: Todoist â Lower entry price and mature free tier. ThinkDoneâs pricing reflects the AI costs but is higher.
Reliability and Maturity
Todoist:
- 17 years in production
- 99.99% uptime over past 12 months
- Massive user base testing edge cases
- Well-documented and stable
ThinkDone:
- Launched 2024
- Growing user base
- Actively developing features
- Occasional bugs as expected in newer software
Winner: Todoist â Maturity and battle-testing matter. Todoist is proven reliable. ThinkDone is solid but younger.
Use Case Scenarios
Scenario 1: The Overwhelmed Executive
Profile: 40+ active projects, 200+ open tasks, struggles with âeverything is urgentâ
Todoist: Provides excellent organization with filters and labels. Can create custom views like âoverdue | today & p1â to surface urgency. But requires you to correctly prioritize 200+ tasks and realistically estimate your capacity. Doesnât challenge your priorities or help you see patterns.
ThinkDone: Morning planning session reviews all projects, identifies which ones are actually stuck vs. just not started, asks hard questions about what actually matters this week, and helps build a realistic daily plan from the chaos. Might challenge you: âYouâve deferred the strategic planning task five days in a row. Whatâs blocking it?â
Better choice: ThinkDone â The bottleneck isnât organization, itâs strategic thinking. ThinkDone forces the conversation this person needs.
Scenario 2: The Organized Achiever
Profile: Clear priorities, strong personal system, just needs reliable tracking
Todoist: Perfect fit. Fast task capture, sophisticated organization, works everywhere. Stays out of your way and lets you execute your system efficiently.
ThinkDone: Planning conversations might feel unnecessary if you already know exactly what to work on. The intelligence features are solving a problem you donât have.
Better choice: Todoist â Donât pay for planning intelligence you donât need. Todoistâs speed and reliability are what matters here.
Scenario 3: The Cross-Platform Professional
Profile: Windows at work, iPhone personally, sometimes on Linux, needs web access
Todoist: Works perfectly on all platforms with instant sync. Browser extension captures tasks from anywhere. Native apps on every platform.
ThinkDone: Web app works, but native apps are in development. No Windows/Linux desktop apps yet.
Better choice: Todoist â Platform coverage wins. ThinkDone isnât ready for this use case yet.
Scenario 4: The Serial Procrastinator
Profile: Has tasks organized perfectly, just never does them. Classic âplanning over executionâ problem.
Todoist: Will enable more sophisticated planning and organization, which might actually make the problem worse. Procrastination isnât solved by better task organization.
ThinkDone: Forces daily commitment to specific tasks with time estimates. The planning conversation includes asking âWhat usually stops you from doing this?â and âWhatâs the smallest version of this you could do today?â Accountability through conversation.
Better choice: ThinkDone â The issue is decision-making and commitment, not organization. ThinkDone addresses the psychological blockers directly.
Scenario 5: The Team Leader
Profile: Manages a team, needs to coordinate work, assign tasks, track progress
Todoist: Business tier provides shared projects, task assignment, comments, team inbox. Mature collaboration features that work reliably.
ThinkDone: No team features yet (on roadmap for late 2025).
Better choice: Todoist â By default. ThinkDone doesnât compete in the team space yet.
The Integration Opportunity
Hereâs what most comparison reviews miss: these tools can work together brilliantly.
Morning routine:
- Open ThinkDone (15 minutes)
- Have the planning conversation
- Get a prioritized, time-estimated daily plan
- Transfer the top 8-10 tasks to Todoistâs âTodayâ view
- Close ThinkDone
During the day:
- Use Todoist for execution â fast task capture, checking items off, reorganizing as needed
- Todoistâs cross-platform sync means your plan is available everywhere
- Quick task entry throughout the day goes into Todoistâs Inbox
Evening:
- Quick review in Todoist
- Incomplete items automatically become inputs for tomorrowâs ThinkDone planning session
This workflow combines ThinkDoneâs strategic planning strength with Todoistâs tactical execution excellence. You get the best of both: intelligence at the planning layer, speed at the execution layer.
Isn't using two tools more complex than using one?
Sometimes, yes. But consider: you probably use separate tools for email and calendar even though many email apps have calendars. Why? Because theyâre solving different problems. ThinkDone solves the planning problem, Todoist solves the execution problem. Using both is like having a strategic advisor and a reliable assistant â they serve complementary functions.
What Real Users Say
I spent time in Todoistâs subreddit and ThinkDoneâs user community looking for common themes. Hereâs what surfaced:
Todoist Users Love:
- Speed and reliability (âIt just works, every timeâ)
- Natural language parsing (âFastest task entry anywhereâ)
- Cross-platform consistency (âFeels the same on every deviceâ)
- Filters for power users (âOnce you master filters, itâs incredibly powerfulâ)
Todoist Users Complain About:
- âI have 200 tasks and no idea where to startâ
- âEverything ends up as P1 and I still donât know whatâs actually importantâ
- âItâs great at organizing tasks but doesnât help me decide what to doâ
- âI spend more time organizing my tasks than actually doing themâ
ThinkDone Users Love:
- âFinally stops me from overcommittingâ
- âThe planning conversation catches things I would have forgottenâ
- âIt asks the questions I should be asking myself but donâtâ
- âWent from 40-item daily lists to realistic 12-item plansâ
ThinkDone Users Complain About:
- âWish it had all of Todoistâs organizational featuresâ
- âPlanning sessions sometimes feel slow compared to just adding tasks quicklyâ
- âNeed mobile apps and better cross-platform supportâ
- âStill rough edges and occasional bugsâ
The pattern is clear: Todoist users love the execution but struggle with prioritization. ThinkDone users love the planning but miss some execution features.
The Bottom Line
This isnât a winner-takes-all comparison. These tools solve different problems.
Todoist is the best task manager for people who:
- Know what they need to do
- Want speed and reliability over guidance
- Work across multiple platforms
- Need mature, proven software
- Prefer manual control over AI assistance
ThinkDone is the best planning partner for people who:
- Struggle with prioritization
- Want AI intelligence to guide daily decisions
- Need help building realistic plans
- Are comfortable with newer software
- Value strategic conversation over task organization
Both together work for people who:
- Want strategic intelligence AND tactical excellence
- Are willing to use two tools for complementary purposes
- Have complex professional lives requiring both planning and execution support
of to-do items never get completed
iDoneThis analysis, 2015
That 41% statistic isnât about poor task managers. Itâs about poor planning. Having a better tool for tracking tasks youâll never do doesnât solve the problem. Having a conversation that prevents you from adding unrealistic tasks in the first place â thatâs what moves the needle.
Todoist is exceptional at task management. ThinkDone addresses the problem that comes before task management: deciding what belongs on the list in the first place.
You might need one or the other. You might need both. But understanding the distinction between task management and planning intelligence is the first step to choosing wisely.
Because the most perfectly organized task list doesnât help if youâre working on the wrong things.
And thatâs the problem ThinkDone was built to solve.
Comparison based on Todoist version 10.8 and ThinkDone version 1.2 (February 2025). Tested over 30 days with real-world projects and tasks. Neither company paid for this review.
Keep Reading

Todoist vs Things 3: The Definitive Comparison for 2025
Todoist and Things 3 represent opposite approaches to task management. After using both for six months, here's the honest comparison of features, philosophy, and which tool fits which workflow.

Best AI Productivity Apps in 2025: 9 Tools That Actually Think For You
We tested every major AI productivity app. Here's what nobody's talking about: which ones actually use intelligence to plan your day, and which ones just slapped GPT into their settings menu and called it AI.

Todoist: The Complete Review â 17 Years of Getting Tasks Done
Todoist has spent 17 years perfecting the art of task capture and organization. This comprehensive review covers its natural language parsing, Karma system, filters, and why 35M+ users trust it daily â plus the limitations that matter when you're ready to level up.

